The Views and Opinions Expressed...

I remember from my childhood being in the room when my parents where watching the news and hearing an announcement "the views and opinions in the following editorial do not necessarily reflect those of this station blah blah blah..." I don't remember exactly how the rest went.

video wall

Well a few days ago when I was giving my site a once over I clicked on one of the videos on my video wall widget. If you haven't checked it out yet there's a link to it at the end of this post but stay here first, please. I chose the video because the trainer appeared in more than one of the frames. His video made complete sense and I was in total agreement with him. He was discussing a strategy that some people claim cannot be done, but it can and he did a good job of explaining how. So I decided to check out another video of his. Within 11 seconds of this video I realized my opinion is the complete opposite of his in regards to core training. He stated core training was one of the biggest wastes of time in the gym. He feels it's the most ineffective and dangerous thing you could do in the gym. He recommends that you work each muscle group independently and then do some crunches or leg lifts for the abs and forget about doing core training. I disagree. First let me say this: All exercise is good. Some is better than others for specific goals, but the health benefits of exercise always makes it worthwhile. Second, all physical activity, proper exercise included, has some possible risk of injury. The risks increases with lack of supervision, poor instruction, and improper progression.

Beyond the fact that I believe that core training can be very effective and when done properly is safe, I take issue with the fact that the trainer did not specifically address any particular group of exercisers before making his bold statement. There are people who can get away without doing any direct core training- advanced strength athletes, bodybuilders and physique models who have been working out enough to know how to effectively stabilize the trunk and receive plenty enough core work through training the rest of their body. Most of these people usually do some form of exercise directed at the muscles of the core anyways.
But this does not apply to everyone. Athletes and beginners that lack adequate core strength and stability definitely benefit from regular direct core training. Not to mention that some of us enjoy exercising with a stability ball, or find it fun doing things on dyna-discs, balance boards and airex cushions. Does that mean we should quit since we're wasting our time doing such 'ineffective, dangerous' stuff? I don't think so.
Also, the core consists of more than just the abs.

I always take issue when fitness 'professionals' make any sort of statement that will possibly direct someone away from exercising. Had he at the beginning stated “This advice is for those of you who exercise or train for ____" then I may not have written this post. But since he basically sounded as if he knows what every exerciser's goal is I feel I had to inform the visitors of Aaron Harris fitness of my stance on core training. So I'd like to leave you with two things:

1.Before you take the advice of someone make sure the person giving the advice knows why you are exercising and what your goals are.

2.The views, opinions, positions or strategies expressed in the videos appearing on the video wall are those of the person/persons presenting in the video, and do not necessarily reflect the views, opinions, positions or strategies of Aaron Harris fitness.

Here's a link to the video wall: Video Widget Link

If you watch any of the videos and have a question about the topic or want my opinion about it be sure to leave a comment and include the link to the video's window or tab.

 

Comments   

 
FatFighterTV
# FatFighterTV 2010-03-01 20:23
All I have to say is I LOVE core training - Pilates, stability ball, balance board - bring it on! :-)
Reply | Reply with quote | Quote | Report to administrator
 
 
Aaron
# Aaron 2010-03-01 22:12
The ball is definitely one of my favorite fitness tools. I think it adds fun to any workout.
Reply | Reply with quote | Quote | Report to administrator
 
 
Mitch
# Mitch 2010-03-06 13:04
Interesting post, and you're correct here. There's always this debate about training overall, in every field, as to what's appropriate and not appropriate for both everyone and for specific people. It behooves most of us to determine that for most things they're not applicable for everyone in every instance.

Of course, you're talking core training, and I have no idea what that is either. lol
Reply | Reply with quote | Quote | Report to administrator
 
 
Aaron
# Aaron 2010-03-07 01:08
Hi Mitch,

Ha ha :D Well when you want to find out about core training hopefully you'll come back here and not to a site that will tell you it's a waste of time.
Thanks for stopping by and commenting. I hope you'll visit again.
Reply | Reply with quote | Quote | Report to administrator
 
 
Anne Moss
# Anne Moss 2010-03-08 03:20
I think you bring up a very important point that's true not only for fitness trainers. Even doctors can have opinions about medical issues and no, they usually do not bother telling you that they're giving you their opinion rather than fact.
Reply | Reply with quote | Quote | Report to administrator
 
 
Aaron
# Aaron 2010-03-08 09:06
Very true Anne. I think that can apply to many different fields as well.
Reply | Reply with quote | Quote | Report to administrator
 

Add comment

If you want your comment to be published please use your real name. Using your website's topic or your business' name will cause your comment to be unpublished.


Security code
Refresh

Fitness blog

Top Fitness Sites

Fitness blog Top health_fitness blogs Health Blogs - Blog Rankings blog search directory Top HealthCare Sites







Copyright © 2009- 2013 Aaron Harris Fitness. All Rights Reserved.    Privacy Policy.

Wednesday the 23rd.